Young Living vs doTERRA (2026): Prices, Pay Plans, Lawsuits and Which to Join

Affiliate Disclosure: There are no affiliate links in this Young Living vs doTERRA comparison, and I don't earn anything if you join or buy from either company. My affiliate disclosure page, linked in the footer, explains how this site makes money.

Income Disclaimer: Any income figures on this page come from the companies' own disclosures, named and linked next to them, and they do not guarantee results. The majority of MLM participants earn little to no income. See our full income disclaimer for details.

Health Disclaimer: This comparison is for information only and is not medical advice. What a product does is stated here only as the company says it. Talk to your healthcare provider before using essential oils, especially if you are pregnant, nursing, on medication or have a medical condition. See our full health disclaimer for details.

If someone invited you to an oils class lately, it was probably for Young Living or doTERRA: two of the best-known essential oil MLMs, both in Utah, with a shared history most members never hear about. The question people bring me: which one should I join, if either?

Quick verdict: As products, they're closer than either side admits. Single oils cost about the same, both quality programs are company-run, and both have FDA warning letters on record. As a business, both companies' own income reports show most sellers earn little or nothing. Want oils? You don't need to join either. Want the business? Pick the people, not the logo.

I've been inside eight network marketing companies since 2004, including Youngevity, but never either of these. Here I put my Young Living review and doTERRA review side by side, plus both companies' membership and kit pages, read on the dates shown.

Young Living vs doTERRA at a Glance

Young Living (1993, Lehi, Utah) is the older company, run by co-founder Mary Young. doTERRA was started in 2008 in Pleasant Grove, Utah, by former Young Living executives. Both are private, both sell oils through a monthly-order MLM, and both publish income figures.

Young LivingdoTERRA
Founded19932008 (April)
HeadquartersLehi, UtahPleasant Grove, Utah
FoundersD. Gary Young (1949 to 2018) and Mary YoungSeven founders, including David Stirling, Emily Wright and Dr. David K. Hill
Ownership and leaderPrivate; Mary Young, co-founder and CEOPrivate; David Stirling, CEO again since February 2026
Sellers are calledBrand PartnersWellness Advocates
Quality programSeed to Seal (the company's own)CPTG, "Certified Pure Tested Grade" (the company's own)
Lavender, 15 ml, retail / member$36.51 / $27.75 (Nov 22, 2026)$38.67 / $29.00 (Oct 15, 2026 copy)
Starter kits$115 to $280 (Nov 22, 2026, sale running)Basic Kit $200 retail, $150 wholesale (Aug 11, 2026 copy)
Member discount24%25%
Income headlineMedian US Brand Partner earned $0 in 202531% of entry-level Wellness Advocates earned a commission in 2022
FDA warning letters2014 and 20222014
FTCNo FTC letter foundFTC warning letter, April 2020

Sources for every row are in the sections below.

Founding, Headquarters and Who Owns Each

Young Living (1993) is at 1538 W. Sandalwood Dr., Lehi, Utah, per its own site. doTERRA (April 2008) is at 389 South 1300 West, Pleasant Grove, Utah, the address on its 2020 FTC letter. Both are privately held.

Young Living. Its Executive Team page lists "Mary Young, Co-founder and CEO"; she took over as CEO in 2015. Gary Young died on May 12, 2018, per the company's announcement. His record before Young Living, including a 1983 misdemeanor plea for practicing medicine without a license, is in my D. Gary Young profile.

doTERRA. Seven people founded it: David Stirling, Emily Wright, Dr. David K. Hill, Corey Lindley, Greg Cook, Rob Young and Mark Wolfert. Stirling stepped away as CEO in 2022 and returned on February 3, 2026. My doTERRA founders profile covers all seven.

I found no sale, merger or outside owner for either.

What Happened Between Young Living and doTERRA?

doTERRA was started in 2008 by former Young Living executives (Stirling, Wright and Hill), and Young Living sued them in 2012 in Utah's Fourth District Court, claiming trade-secret theft. A jury rejected Young Living's claims in 2017, and in July 2018 a judge ordered Young Living to pay about $1.8 million of doTERRA's attorney costs. After the jury verdict, Judge Christine Johnson found a trade-secret claim was brought in bad faith and called Young Living's timeline "a knowing falsification of the evidence," as KSL reported on July 12, 2018. Young Living told the Deseret News the ruling did not address the merits; the paper reported an appeal was pending. I could not find how the appeal ended.

Some pages still call this a settlement. It wasn't: doTERRA won at trial and on fees. None of it was a member's fight, but it explains the prickliness between the two communities.

Products and Prices Side by Side

The catalogs line up closely: single oils, a clove-and-cinnamon protective blend (Thieves vs On Guard), diffusers, cleaners and supplements. Single oils are within a few dollars of each other, and each quality program is the company's own, not an outside certification.

ProductYoung Living (retail / member)doTERRA (retail / wholesale)
Lavender, 15 ml$36.51 / $27.75, youngliving.com, Nov 22, 2026$38.67 / $29.00, official page, Oct 15, 2026 copy
Frankincense, 15 ml$114.14 / $86.75, youngliving.com, Nov 22, 2026$105.33 / $79.00, official page, Nov 4, 2026 copy
Protective blend, 15 mlThieves, $52.30 / $39.75, Nov 22, 2026On Guard, $52.00 / $39.00, Aug 11, 2026 copy

doTERRA's US site blocked my reads on November 22, 2026, so its prices come from Internet Archive copies of its official pages, dated above.

Thieves lists clove, lemon, cinnamon bark, eucalyptus and rosemary on its label; On Guard lists wild orange, clove, cinnamon bark, eucalyptus and rosemary. My Thieves review and On Guard review go label by label. The rest of the six I've reviewed: Thieves Household Cleaner, NingXia Red ($110.53 for two 750 ml bottles, Nov 22, 2026), the Young Living diffusers and doTERRA's Deep Blue Rub ($51.33 retail, June 11, 2026 copy).

"Therapeutic grade." The ad industry's review board ruled on both programs. It recommended on November 24, 2020 that Young Living stop calling its oils "therapeutic grade," and announced on March 31, 2021 that doTERRA should drop "Certified Pure Therapeutic Grade," what CPTG used to stand for. Both said they would comply while disagreeing.

Starter Kits and Membership: What It Costs to Get In

Young Living gives members 24% off with a Loyalty Order or an order over 100 PV; doTERRA gives 25% off, with an annual $25 renewal fee. Starter kits ran $115 to $280 at Young Living and $200 retail for doTERRA's Basic Kit.

Young Living (read November 22, 2026):

  • Kits on its starter kits page ran from $115.00 (the Make a Shift kits) to $280.00 (Premium Starter Bundle with Aria Diffuser); the Adobe Mist bundle was $165.00, marked "Sale."
  • Its Loyalty Rewards page gives "a 24 percent discount on all purchases," and points on monthly 50+ PV loyalty orders: 10% for months 1 to 3, 20% for months 4 to 24, then 25%.
  • I found no published membership or renewal fee; the Brand Partner sign-up page redirected to the homepage when I tried it.

doTERRA (official pages, Internet Archive copies):

  • The Basic Kit, a Pebble Diffuser plus oils, was $200.00 retail and $150.00 wholesale on August 11, 2026; the same page listed the Essentials Kit at $333.33 / $250.00.
  • The Membership Comparison page (August 9, 2026) offers Wholesale Customers "25% off retail prices," 10% to 30% of orders back in points, and "a free product after the annual $25.00 renewal fee."
  • An older doTERRA FAQ about a 2023 promotion mentions "the $35 enrollment fee." I could not confirm today's sign-up fee, so check it at checkout.

The Pay Plans in Plain Words

Both pay commissions through ranks on sales by you and the people you bring in. doTERRA publishes a 100 PV monthly order rule; Young Living's current plan document isn't on its public US site, so I can't quote its rules.

Young Living. Its income disclosure lists ten ranks, Associate to Royal Crown Diamond, paid under "the Young Living Sales Compensation Plan," and says Brand Partners with no commissions for 12 months become customer accounts. Product pages offer "25% credit when someone shops your link."

doTERRA. The membership page says, "Wellness Advocates commit to placing a 100 PV order each month to qualify for commissions," and adds, "Results vary. Average earnings are less." Its 2023 report names an entry level, Builder ranks (Manager to Premier) and Leader ranks (Silver to Presidential Diamond).

In both, the money starts with your own monthly order.

What the Income Disclosures Show

Both companies' own reports say most sellers earn little: a $0 median at Young Living in 2025, and only 31% of doTERRA's entry-level Wellness Advocates paid any commission in 2022. Both are gross figures, before costs.

Young Living, from the Young Living 2026 U.S. Income Disclosure Statement (dated March 1, 2026, covering 2025; the copy I read is archived by Sequence Inc.):

  • 73.9% of Brand Partners were Associates, with an average of $12 for the year and a median of $0.
  • 17.1% were Stars, averaging $310 (median $236).
  • Across all Brand Partners, the average was $778 and the median was $0.
  • Each rank from Platinum up held less than 0.1% of Brand Partners. Royal Crown Diamonds averaged $1,240,335.

doTERRA, from the Annual dōTERRA Business Builders Report 2023 (covering 2022; copy hosted by Truth in Advertising):

  • About 400,000+ US Wellness Advocates made a purchase, and doTERRA paid commissions to over 196,000 of them.
  • 77% were entry level. Only 31% of those earned a commission, and those who did averaged $394 for the year.
  • Builders were about 22%. Leaders (Silver and up) were about 1%. Silvers averaged $31,392 and Presidential Diamonds $1,396,327.

These aren't like-for-like: different years, different layouts, and doTERRA has newer editions I couldn't read. The shape is the same: a small group at the top earns most of the money.

Not sure network marketing is worth your time?

I put together the training I wish I had when I started. No pitch, and no pressure to join anything. Just the fundamentals that decide whether this actually works for you.

Get the free training

Regulators and Lawsuits: Both Records

Both companies received FDA warning letters dated September 22, 2014, about sellers promoting oils to treat diseases. Young Living also has a 2022 FDA letter and a 2017 federal guilty plea. doTERRA has a 2020 FTC warning letter and a 2021 packaging recall. Neither has been found by a court to be a pyramid scheme.

If you're a member, this can be hard to read. Most of it is about what some sellers posted, not what you did. But you deserve the whole record in one place.

Young Living

  • September 22, 2014, FDA warning letter about consultants promoting products for conditions including "viral infections (including ebola), Parkinson's disease, autism"; twelve products, Thieves among them, called unapproved new drugs (archived letter).
  • September 18, 2017, federal guilty plea to misdemeanor rosewood and spikenard oil trafficking charges under the Lacey Act and Endangered Species Act: $760,000 in all plus five years' probation. The company had disclosed the rosewood violations itself (DOJ).
  • 2018, the doTERRA fee ruling described above.
  • 2019 to 2023, class actions. Two pyramid-scheme suits: O'Shaughnessy (after a Fifth Circuit arbitration ruling of April 28, 2020) was reported dismissed in 2021, and Penhall was voluntarily dismissed with prejudice on November 22, 2023, after a reported settlement. A health-marketing suit (Branchaud) was dismissed in February 2021 (TINA). None found Young Living to be a pyramid scheme.
  • 2020 and 2022, ad-industry rulings. DSSRC asked Young Living to police seller health claims (closed February 19, 2020); the "therapeutic grade" ruling followed that November; a March 29, 2022 follow-up flagged COVID-19 claims, and the video came down.
  • June 10, 2022, FDA warning letter to Mary Young about consultant posts on products including Thieves and NingXia Red (FDA).
  • FTC: I found no FTC warning letter to Young Living. It was not among the ten MLMs in the FTC's April 24, 2020 COVID-19 letters.
  • August 17, 2000, a workplace death at Young Living Farms in Mona, Utah, when a homemade distiller ruptured, per Utah's safety agency as reported by Skeptical Inquirer.

doTERRA

  • September 22, 2014, FDA warning letter about consultants promoting products including On Guard, Frankincense and Lavender for conditions including "viral infections (including ebola), bacterial infections, cancer" (archived letter).
  • March 2020, DSSRC case 17-2020. Distributor posts about reversing Type II diabetes and six-figure incomes, found unsupported and removed (DSSRC).
  • April 24, 2020, FTC warning letter saying seller posts "unlawfully advertise that certain products treat or prevent Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)" and misrepresented likely income (FTC).
  • October 2020 and March 2021, NAD and NARB. After an S.C. Johnson challenge, the NAD found no reasonable basis for mood and emotional benefit claims; the NARB then recommended dropping "Certified Pure Therapeutic Grade."
  • April 1, 2021, CPSC recall of about 1.3 million 10 mL roll-ons of Deep Blue, PastTense and Deep Blue Touch that contain methyl salicylate and lacked child-resistant packaging (CPSC). Not the Deep Blue Rub tube.
  • November 2021, DSSRC case 51-2021. New health and income posts, removed within 48 hours (DSSRC).
  • 2023, three distributors. The Justice Department sued three high-level distributors for the FTC over COVID-19 claims; each agreed to a $15,000 civil penalty. doTERRA was not a defendant (FTC, March 3, 2023).
  • November 2024 and January 2026, DSSRC closures over distributor earnings and product posts, removed or revised (2024, 2026).

If anyone tells you either company's oils treat a disease, that is exactly the kind of claim these letters were about.

What Users of Each Have Reported

On Trustpilot, read November 22, 2026, Young Living held 3.2 out of 5 from 243 reviews and doTERRA held 3.7 out of 5 from 655. Both pages note the company hasn't invited reviews recently, so the reviews may not be representative.

  • Price. A Young Living reviewer on Trustpilot (November 11, 2026) recommended the oils but called the dish products very expensive. Kristen at The Frugal Girl couldn't see a difference between a Young Living starter-kit diffuser and a $20 Amazon one.
  • Service and loyalty orders. Users of doTERRA have reported trouble with refunds and replacements and confusion over the loyalty program on Trustpilot, including a March 7, 2026 review headed "Signed up for rewards without permission."
  • People like the products. A Thieves Cleaner user said on Reddit they liked it enough to look for a cheaper version, and a longtime Young Living customer on Trustpilot (2019) praised the bonus oils for a monthly order.
  • Head to head. Erin's Home on YouTube tested On Guard and Thieves as cleaners for seven days and says the video is not sponsored.

Which One Should You Join, If Either?

If you want oils, you don't need to join either. If you want the business, the company matters less than your sponsor and your own plan to find customers, because neither company's numbers favor a newcomer.

If you just want the products: Buy the ones you like, at member price only if you'd order monthly anyway. My two company reviews, linked at the top, each list cheaper non-MLM options.

If you want the business: Choose the sponsor, not the brand. Ask them for the income disclosure, what they spend each month, and how they find customers beyond friends and family.

If you're already in one: You weren't foolish to join. Good people joined both in good faith, and the skills you've built (talking to people, sharing products you like, running a small community) carry over to whatever you do next.


One More Thing...

Here's the thing most people miss about Young Living and doTERRA: the oils might be fine, but the business model only works if you can market. And that's not something most uplines teach.

Whether you pick one of these two, another company, or none, the fundamentals don't change. If you want to see the approach I recommend for growing any network marketing business using real digital marketing strategies, check out The Sponsoring System. It's free to get started.


Frequently Asked Questions

Young Living vs doTERRA: which is better?

Neither is clearly better. Single-oil prices are close: on the official US pages, 15 ml of lavender was $36.51 at Young Living (Nov 22, 2026) and $38.67 at doTERRA (Oct 15, 2026 copy). Both quality programs are the companies' own, and both have FDA warning letters on record. As a business, both income disclosures show most sellers earn little. Pick on the products you like and the person who would sponsor you.

What happened between Young Living and doTERRA?

Former Young Living executives started doTERRA in 2008, and Young Living sued them in 2012 over alleged trade secrets. A jury rejected its claims in 2017, and in July 2018 a Utah judge ordered Young Living to pay about $1.8 million of doTERRA's attorney costs, finding a trade-secret claim was brought in bad faith. It was not a settlement.

Who is doTERRA's biggest competitor?

I don't have a market-share source I trust, so I won't rank them. The company people compare doTERRA to most is Young Living: both are essential oil MLMs based in Utah, and three of doTERRA's founders came from Young Living.

Is Young Living or doTERRA cheaper?

It depends on the product. On the official US pages, Young Living lavender was $36.51 (Nov 22, 2026) and doTERRA's $38.67 (Oct 15, 2026 copy), but doTERRA frankincense was $105.33 (Nov 4, 2026 copy) and Young Living's $114.14 (Nov 22, 2026). Members get 24% off at Young Living (with a Loyalty Order or an order over 100 PV) and 25% off at doTERRA. Young Living's kits started at $115 on Nov 22, 2026, during a Black Friday promotion.

Can you make money with Young Living or doTERRA?

A few people do, but most don't. Young Living's 2026 disclosure says the median US Brand Partner earned $0 in 2025. doTERRA's report for 2022 says 77% of US Wellness Advocates were entry level, only 31% of those earned a commission, and those who did averaged $394 for the year. Both are gross figures, before costs.

Why do people quit Young Living or doTERRA?

I can only go by what people have posted. Trustpilot reviews of both mention price, and doTERRA reviewers mention loyalty-program confusion. Money matters too: both companies' income reports show most sellers earn little, while a monthly order keeps costing.

About the Author

Matt Hall

Founder, The Sponsoring System · Lansing, Michigan

I am a marketing, software, and AI entrepreneur who got into network marketing in 2004 and has been a distributor across eight companies since. I have sat in the meetings, bought the products, and worked the comp plans firsthand. I write these reviews from the inside out, for people trying to decide whether to join, or how to leave, an MLM. No recruiting pitch, no pile on. Just what I actually found.

More about me →

Related Posts