Young Living Thieves Review (2026): What Is in It, What It Costs, and the FDA Letters

Young Living Thieves is the product most people hear about first. If someone in your life sells Young Living, you have probably been offered it. It is the blend they diffuse in the fall, rub on their feet in winter and recommend for almost everything. So the question people bring to it is simple: is a $52 bottle of oil worth it, and does it do what the posts say?

So I did what I always do: I dug in. I read the official label and price, both FDA warning letters that name Thieves, and what users say.

Quick verdict: Thieves is a real, well-made blend of five common essential oils with a scent a lot of people love. It is also expensive for what it is, and it has been the subject of two FDA warning letters over disease claims made by sellers. If you love the smell, you can buy a blend with the same five oils for a fraction of the price.

What Is Young Living Thieves?

Thieves Essential Oil Blend (item #3423) is one of the signature products of Young Living, the Lehi, Utah essential oils company founded in 1993. The company calls it "the original Thieves blend" and says it has been "a bestseller for 30+ years." On the US site it comes in one size: a 15 ml bottle.

The name comes from an old story. Young Living says its founder, Gary Young, was "inspired by tales of medieval thieves who covered themselves in spices and plant essences." The company says the blend gives a "warm, spicy-citrus scent," and it suggests diffusing it, adding it to cleaning products "for an aromatic boost," diluting it on the bottoms of your feet "during cold winter months," and adding a drop to mouthwash to freshen breath.

Those are the company's words. I am not going to tell you what it does for your body, because nobody has shown that in a way that would hold up, and as you will see below, the FDA has twice stepped in when sellers tried.

The wider Thieves line

Thieves is also a whole brand at Young Living. The "Thieves Home" category on the US site listed 32 items when I checked, all built around the blend. A sample, with prices as of November 22, 2026:

Thieves productLoyalty / discount priceRegular price
Thieves Essential Oil Blend (15 ml)$39.75$52.30
Thieves Roll-On$34.25$45.07
Thieves Cleaner$24.00$31.58
Thieves Foaming Hand Soap Concentrate$28.00$36.84
Thieves Whitening Toothpaste$13.25$17.43
Thieves Cough Drops$23.75$31.25
Thieves Home Cleaning Kit$94.00$123.68

The Thieves Household Cleaner is the most famous item in that list, and it is a different product with its own questions, so I am covering it in a separate review. This page is about the oil blend.

What's In It

The label lists five oils and nothing else:

Ingredient (as labeled)Part usedOrigin the company names
Clove (Syzygium aromaticum)bud oilnot stated
Lemon (Citrus limon)peel oilArgentina
Cinnamon (Cinnamomum verum)bark oilnot stated
Eucalyptus (Eucalyptus radiata)leaf oilnot stated
Rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis)leaf oilMorocco

The directions on the official page are worth reading closely, because they are more careful than most of what you will hear from sellers:

  • Topical: "Dilute 1 drop with 4 drops of V-6 Vegetable Oil Complex. Test on a small area of skin on the underside of arm."
  • Aromatic: "Diffuse up to 10 minutes 3 times daily."
  • Safety: "Keep out of reach of children. For external use only. Keep away from eyes and mucous membranes." The label also says to talk to a health professional first if you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication or have a medical condition, and to avoid direct sunlight for up to 12 hours after applying it.

Note the words "for external use only." Keep them in mind when you get to the FDA section.

Price and Where It Is Sold

Here is what the official US product page showed on November 22, 2026:

Price lineAmount
Regular (retail) price, 15 ml$52.30
Discount price (Loyalty Order or an order above 100 PV)$39.75
PV (the volume credited in the pay plan)39.25
Black Friday price in the cart that day (temporary)$36.61

Source: the official Thieves product page. That works out to about $3.49 per ml at the regular price and about $2.65 per ml at the discount price.

The discount runs through what Young Living now calls Loyalty Rewards. According to the official Loyalty Rewards page, signing up unlocks "our exclusive 24 percent discount" and a monthly loyalty order. Placing a loyalty order of 50 PV or more each month earns points back (10% of PV for the first three months, rising to 20% and then 25% the longer you stay), plus free gifts at 2, 3, 6, 9 and 12 months. The product page also notes, "Your order creates your account," so buying once makes you a customer account holder.

That structure is the part to think about. The best price comes with a monthly order. That is fine if you would buy every month anyway. It is less fine if you sign up for the discount and end up with a shelf of oils.

You will also find Thieves on Amazon, but not from Young Living. The listing I checked was sold by a third-party seller called Epic Global, at about $57.53 on Amazon as of November 22, 2026, which is more than the company's own regular price.

What Users Report

I looked for the real experiences, the good and the bad. Here is what came up most.

The scent is the main reason people love it. Reviewers on ChickAdvisor's Thieves page call it a diffuser favorite and describe a "fresh, clean smell." Amazon's review summary for the third-party Thieves listing puts fragrance and scent at the top of what buyers mention, with hundreds of mentions. A YouTube creator who loves the blend, Sue Sturos, walks through its name and how she uses the wider Thieves line in The Thieves Oil Legend.

Some people can't stand it. In an r/antiMLM thread called Thieves smells disgusting, a user describes the Thieves hand soap at her church as smelling "like gross potpourri." Others in the same thread said they like it because they love fall spice scents. Another reply pointed out that it contains cinnamon, clove and eucalyptus oils, which can be too harsh for young children. The scent splits people.

Price comes up a lot. One ChickAdvisor reviewer called it "a bit pricy especially for a college student." Amazon's summary says opinions on value for money are mixed.

It can feel hot on the skin. A ChickAdvisor reviewer recommended a carrier oil because "it is quite potent and can feel like it's burning your skin otherwise." That matches the label's own one-to-four dilution.

Authenticity worries on Amazon. Because the Amazon listing is a reseller, Amazon's summary notes that some buyers confirm it is real Young Living product "while others doubt its authenticity."

People look for alternatives after leaving. In an r/antiMLM thread on the Thieves Cleaner, the poster says she likes it but will not buy more and asks for similar products. A reply notes, "Thieves is an old formula and other companies make their own versions of it."

You will also see plenty of users report that Thieves helped with colds, germs or mold. Those are personal stories, not evidence, and the FDA letters below are what happens when sellers turn stories like that into claims.

Not sure network marketing is worth your time?

I put together the training I wish I had when I started. No pitch, and no pressure to join anything. Just the fundamentals that decide whether this actually works for you.

Get the free training

The Concerns

This is the hard part, and I want to be fair about it. Most people who sell Thieves love the product and believe in it. But the record here is clear, and you should know it before you buy or sell.

The 2014 FDA warning letter

On September 22, 2014, the FDA sent a warning letter to Young Living, addressed to Gary Young as CEO. The letter says that in August 2014 the FDA "reviewed websites and social media accounts (e.g., Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest) for several Young Living essential oil consultants," and found that products "such as, but not limited to, 'Thieves'" were being promoted in ways that made them drugs under federal law.

Thieves is the first product the letter names. The consultant claims the FDA quoted included "Top on my list is Thieves. Thieves is highly anti-microbial . . . it could help against Ebola," and "Ebola Virus can not live in the presence of cinnamon bark (this is in Thieves)." The letter lists conditions consultants promoted the oils for, including viral infections, Parkinson's disease, autism, diabetes and cancer. It concluded that Thieves and eleven other products were unapproved new drugs and misbranded. You can read the 2014 letter in the FDA's archive.

The 2022 FDA warning letter

It happened again. On June 10, 2022, the FDA sent a second warning letter, this time to CEO Mary Young, after reviewing the social media of "several Young Living Consultants in May 2022." It names "Thieves Essential Oil Blend" among the products. One consultant post it quotes, from October 2019, describes a head cold and says, "The remedy, thieves [Essential Oil Blend] under the tongue all day long." The FDA again concluded the products were "unapproved new drugs." Here is the 2022 FDA letter.

Compare that post to the label you read above: "For external use only."

The 2020 DSSRC case

Between those two letters, the watchdog group Truth in Advertising challenged Young Living distributor posts before the Direct Selling Self-Regulatory Council, an industry program run by BBB National Programs. In Case #13-2020, closed February 19, 2020, the posts at issue included a list claiming Thieves for "Cold & Flu, Household Germs, Gingivitis or Bleeding Gums, Strep Throat" and posts about treating UTIs with Thieves capsules. DSSRC recommended that Young Living actively monitor the marketplace for health claims and act on them, up to suspending or terminating accounts. Young Living said it would continue to do so.

What I did not find

I did not find a recall of Thieves Essential Oil Blend. The FTC's April 2020 COVID-19 warning letters went to ten MLM companies, and Young Living was not on that list.

The takeaway is not that Thieves is a bad product. It is that the most popular way it gets sold, with health stories, is the way that keeps drawing regulators. If you are a distributor who shared posts like these in good faith, you are not alone, and the fix is simple: talk about what it smells like and how you use it around the house, and leave health claims out.

Product Alternatives

If you like the smell and want the oil without the monthly order, several brands sell blends built from the same family of oils. These are the ones I checked, all in stock on November 22, 2026:

BlendOils on the labelSizePrice on Amazon (Nov 22, 2026)About per ml
NOW Essential Oils Nature's Shieldclove bud, lemon peel, cinnamon bark, Eucalyptus radiata, rosemary leaf1 oz (about 30 ml)about $11.99$0.41
Edens Garden Fighting Fivelemon, cinnamon leaf, Moroccan rosemary, clove bud, two eucalyptus10 mlabout $13.56$1.36
Plant Therapy Germ Fighterlemon, clove bud, Eucalyptus globulus, cinnamon cassia, rosemary30 mlabout $17.99$0.60

NOW Nature's Shield is the closest match on paper: its label lists the same five oils as the Thieves label, down to cinnamon bark and Eucalyptus radiata. Edens Garden and Plant Therapy use cinnamon leaf or cassia and a different eucalyptus, so the scent will be close but not identical. None of these will match Young Living's exact ratios or sourcing, and I am not claiming they will. But at about 41 cents per ml for NOW against $3.49 per ml for Thieves at its regular price, it is worth trying one before you commit to a monthly order.

The same dilution rules apply to all of them. Cinnamon and clove oils are strong.

Should You Sell It?

Thieves is one of the easiest Young Living products to talk about, which is why so many new distributors lead with it. But it sits inside a network marketing business where the discount and points reward monthly orders, and where the income math is hard for most people. I break down the pay plan and the income disclosure in my full Young Living review. If you are comparing essential oil companies, my doTERRA review covers the other big name, and my doTERRA On Guard review looks at its answer to Thieves. If you're deciding between the two companies, my Young Living vs doTERRA comparison puts their kits, pay plans and records side by side.

Whether you go with Young Living Thieves or one of the alternatives above, the real question is: how are you going to sell it? Most distributors are still doing the friends-and-family thing. If you want a better approach, I recommend checking out The Sponsoring System.

Verdict

Having been inside eight network marketing companies since 2004, I have seen how a product like this becomes the thing everyone leads with. Enjoy it for what the company's own label says it is: an aromatic blend you dilute and diffuse. Want to compare it with other products? See my other product reviews and all of my MLM company reviews.

Not sure network marketing is worth your time?

I put together the training I wish I had when I started. No pitch, and no pressure to join anything. Just the fundamentals that decide whether this actually works for you.

Get the free training

About the Author

Matt Hall

Founder, The Sponsoring System · Lansing, Michigan

I am a marketing, software, and AI entrepreneur who got into network marketing in 2004 and has been a distributor across eight companies since. I have sat in the meetings, bought the products, and worked the comp plans firsthand. I write these reviews from the inside out, for people trying to decide whether to join, or how to leave, an MLM. No recruiting pitch, no pile on. Just what I actually found.

More about me →

Related Posts