Jon M. Taylor and MLM: The Critic Behind the 99% Figure, and What Still Applies
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See my full affiliate disclosure for details.
Income Disclaimer: Nothing in this profile is a promise of income. Most people in network marketing earn little or nothing, and your results depend on your effort, your skills and your market. See my full income disclaimer for details.
If you have ever seen the claim that "99% of people in MLM lose money," you have run into the work of Jon M. Taylor, whether you knew his name or not. He was a Utah consumer advocate who spent decades taking pay plans apart, and his numbers still get quoted in news stories and law reviews.
People search "Jon Taylor MLM" to find out who he was, where that figure came from, and whether it holds up. I have been in eight network marketing companies since 2004, so I come at him from the inside. I do not agree with all of his conclusions. But I think his questions are some of the most useful a networker can ask before joining anything. Here's what I found.
Quick verdict: Jon M. Taylor was a serious, credentialed critic who tested Nu Skin himself and then spent decades arguing that recruitment-driven MLMs leave almost everyone with a loss. His 99% figure is his own analysis, not an FTC finding, and the industry disputes it. His checklist of red flags is still worth running on any company you are looking at.
Who Was Jon M. Taylor?
Jon Monson Taylor was born on July 1, 1937, in Salt Lake City, Utah, and died on August 2, 2018, at 81 (Russon Mortuary obituary; Pink Truth).
His obituary says he earned a BS from BYU in 1961, an MBA from BYU in 1965, and "In 1986, he earned a Ph.D. in Applied Psychology from the University of Utah." It calls him "a consumer advocate for the past 30 years" and credits him with the "analysis of over 300 multi-level marketing companies (MLMs), testifying before the FTC." In his own author bio he wrote, "I have initiated or helped to start over 40 businesses, many of them sales oriented" (Seeking Alpha).
He was based in Bountiful, Utah. His letters to the FTC carry the letterhead of the Consumer Awareness Institute at an address in "Bountiful, UT 84010" (FTC comment, May 24, 2009), and a 2008 Associated Press story called him "A network marketing critic, Jon Taylor of Bountiful" (Deseret News).
How he got into it
He started from the inside. He wrote that his work on MLMs "began with a one-year test" of "the Nu Skin program for a year in 1994" (Seeking Alpha). In his book he describes dragging "my suspicious wife JoAnn out to a couple of Nu Skin opportunity meetings," and says she eventually told him, "It's Nu Skin or me - take your pick."
After that he wrote, "I founded the nonprofit Consumer Awareness Institute to conduct research and teach seminars related to personal finance and entrepreneurship" (book, Chapter 1, filed with the FTC). He also worked with Robert FitzPatrick, saying he served "as a Director of Pyramid Scheme Alert (with Robert FitzPatrick as President)." I profile FitzPatrick here.
| Fact | What I found | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Born, died | July 1, 1937, Salt Lake City; August 2, 2018 | obituary |
| Based in | Bountiful, Utah | FTC letter, 2009 |
| Education | BS and MBA, BYU; PhD, University of Utah (1986) | obituary |
| Own MLM test | Nu Skin, 1994 | Seeking Alpha bio |
| Organization | Consumer Awareness Institute (nonprofit) | book, Ch. 1 |
What Jon Taylor Is Known For
He is known for one number and one checklist.
The number is the claim that roughly 99% of MLM participants lose money. The checklist is what he called the "5 Red Flags," a set of pay plan features he said separate a recruitment-driven MLM from a real direct selling business.
If you are weighing Nu Skin, the company he tested, my Nu Skin review covers its products, pay plan and regulatory history.
What He Argued
These are his main arguments, in his own words, with my take as someone who has been in the profession for twenty years.
1. About 99% lose money
In his book he wrote that "wherever I could get the earnings reports of participants in MLMs with these "5 Red Flags" in their pay plan, approximately 99.6% of ALL participants (including dropouts) lost money, after subtracting ALL expenses." He added that under "a more strict interpretation of the data, the loss rate is closer to 99.9%" (book, Ch. 1).
The expenses he counted were "minimal operating expenses and "incentivized purchases" (necessary to qualify for commissions or bonuses)." That is the key to his math. He treated the product you have to buy to stay qualified as a business cost, not as shopping.
My take: whether the real figure is 99% or 90% depends on how you count. But every income disclosure I have read shows most people earning little or nothing, and almost none of them subtract what you spend. On the core point, he was asking the right question.
2. The "5 Red Flags"
He wrote that "five "red flags" or characteristics became apparent that clearly distinguished chain or pyramid selling schemes from legitimate direct selling business-es. The first four applied to all MLMs, the fifth to most." (book, Ch. 1) He presented them at the Economic Crime Summit Conference in 2002 and 2004, and said he used the model "to analyze the compensation plans of over 350 MLMs."
3. "Product-based pyramid schemes"
This was his label for companies that make most of their money from recruiting: "a recruitment-driven MLM, or what I would label a product-based pyramid scheme because such a model leads to horrendous loss rates among participants" (book, Ch. 10).
That is his legal opinion, not a court's. Regulators decide case by case. The FTC's 2016 settlement with Herbalife, which I cover in my Herbalife review, went after a pay plan that rewarded recruiting over retail sales, which is close to the problem he described.
4. Saturation
He argued the model runs out of people: "As an endless chain recruitment system, MLM is flawed, uneconomic, and fraudulent. It is also extremely viral and predatory" (book, Ch. 3).
5. Worse odds than a casino
In a chart he filed with the FTC, he put recruitment-driven MLMs at 99.6% losing money next to roulette at Caesars Palace at 97.1% (Appendix 7E). It is a deliberately harsh comparison. It is also memorable, which is why people still repeat it.
6. Ask the tax preparers
He also tested his numbers another way. He wrote, "I decided to interview tax professionals in several counties - totaling almost 300 of them over a period of several years" (book, Ch. 1). Tracy Coenen revisited that survey on Pink Truth in 2025 (Pink Truth). I profile her here.
Not sure network marketing is worth your time?
I put together the training I wish I had when I started. No pitch, and no pressure to join anything. Just the fundamentals that decide whether this actually works for you.
Get the free trainingHis Work With Regulators
Most critics write blog posts. Taylor also filed with regulators and lobbied lawmakers.
- FTC Business Opportunity Rule, 2006 to 2011. He filed comments on the 2006 and 2008 versions of the rule, including one titled "WHY THE FTC'S PROPOSED (REVISED) BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY RULE SHOULD BE SET ASIDE" (FTC, 2008). In 2008 he wrote that "less than 1% of all participants (including dropouts) in MLM earn a profit."
- The June 2009 FTC workshop. He asked for time on the panel, writing that "I am the only independent (not financed by interested parties affected by RPBOR) consumer advocate on the panel" (FTC, May 24, 2009). In 2011 he wrote, "At my own expense, I traveled to DC to testify at the June 2009 FTC-BOR workshop" (FTC, January 10, 2011).
- January 2011. He wrote to FTC staff again and filed his book, chapter by chapter, as public comments on the rule. The revised rule the FTC was weighing left MLMs out, which is the change he had argued against.
- Utah, 2006. Mother Jones reported in 2011 that "Taylor actively lobbied against the pro-MLM bill" that the Utah legislature passed in 2006, and that Taylor said he pleaded with then-Governor Jon Huntsman not to sign it (Mother Jones, September 13, 2011).
What He Sold and What It Cost
Nothing, as far as I can find. He gave his main book away. His author bio says it "can be downloaded free of charge from my web site" (Seeking Alpha). The Consumer Awareness Institute was a nonprofit, and I found no paid course, coaching program or event of his.
That matters for how you read him. He was not steering readers toward a competing opportunity or a training product.
Books
His obituary says "He wrote and self-published five books on the MLM industry." I could find two.
- The Case (for and) against Multi-level Marketing (Consumer Awareness Institute, 2011). This is the one people mean. I found no Amazon listing. Several chapters are on ftc.gov as the comments he filed, including Chapter 1, Chapter 3 and Chapter 10.
- The Network Marketing Game: Gospel Perspectives on Multi-Level Marketing (1997), illustrated by Cal Grondahl. It is an earlier book, written from a religious point of view, as its subtitle says. Used copies are on Amazon.
If you want to read a modern book in the same vein, I reviewed Robert FitzPatrick's Ponzinomics.
Where He Is Now
Jon Taylor died on August 2, 2018, at 81. Tracy Coenen called him "a prominent fighter against the multi-level marketing industry" in her memorial post (Pink Truth, August 15, 2018).
His work outlived him:
- His website, mlm-thetruth.com, did not load when I tried it on November 22, 2026.
- His FTC filings are still on ftc.gov, linked above.
- Other critics still use his method. A 2019 Fraud Files post called his book "thorough and excellent" (Sequence Inc., 2019), and an April 2025 post walked through his way of turning an income disclosure into a profit-and-loss estimate (Sequence Inc., 2025).
- Legal writers cite him. A 2022 Drexel Law Review article on MLM regulation cites his book many times (Drexel Law Review).
The Concerns and Where People Disagree
There is no lawsuit or regulator action against him that I could find. The disagreement is about his numbers.
- It is not an FTC report. His figure is often described as an FTC study. It is not. In 2019 the trade outlet Direct Selling News wrote that "The report cited in the article was not an official FTC report. It was part of a comment posted on the FTC website," after the Washington Post corrected an article (Direct Selling News, February 1, 2019). That is fair. His analysis deserves to be read as his analysis.
- The industry rejected his method. MLM analyst Len Clements told the FTC in 2008 that "Mr. Taylor's "research" has been formally and completely debunked" and that the Consumer Awareness Institute "is nothing more than Jon Taylor" (FTC, July 14, 2008). I cover that side in my Len Clements profile.
- Nu Skin disagreed. In a statement Taylor reproduced in his own book, Nu Skin said that "Dr. Taylor fails to make the distinction between legitimate network marketing and illegal pyramid schemes."
- His own numbers moved. At different times he gave the loss rate as 99%, 99.6% and 99.9%, and the count of plans he had studied as 300, 350 and more. Critics point to that. I read it as a man updating rough estimates, but it is a reason to treat the exact decimal with care.
My view sits between the two camps. He was right that most people lose money once you count what they buy to stay active. He was too quick, in my opinion, to call nearly every company a pyramid scheme. Both things can be true. I lay out the legal line in my guide to MLM vs pyramid scheme.
How a Networker Can Use His Work
You do not need to agree with him to use his test. Before you join anything:
- Find the income disclosure and read the median, not the top ranks.
- Subtract your required purchases. If you must buy every month to qualify, count that as a cost.
- Add the real costs: events, samples, tools, travel.
- Ask where the pay comes from. If most of it is tied to recruiting rather than sales to outside customers, that is his biggest red flag.
- Check the regulator record on the FTC site and with your state attorney general.
For a view from the industry's own lawyer on the same questions, see my profile of MLM attorney Kevin Thompson.
Who Should Read Him
Read him if you are about to join a company, you are deciding whether to stay, or you lead a team and want to stress-test what you tell people. His questions are free and blunt.
Skip him if you want tactics for building a team. He did not teach that, and he would have told you not to try. More profiles, from trainers to critics, are on the leaders hub.
My Verdict on Jon M. Taylor
Jon Taylor tested a company himself, did not like the math, and spent the rest of his life saying so to anyone who would listen, including the FTC. His famous figure is an estimate, and the industry has good reason to argue with how it gets quoted. But the habit he taught, counting every dollar you spend against every dollar you earn, is the one most networkers skip and the one that would save them the most.
Whatever you take from Jon Taylor, the part most people skip is getting in front of new people online. If you do build in this profession, build it on real customers and your own audience, not just on friends and family. If you want the approach I recommend, check out The Sponsoring System. It's free to get started: start the free series here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was Jon M. Taylor?
Jon M. Taylor was a Utah consumer advocate who spent decades studying multi-level marketing. He held an MBA from BYU and a PhD in Applied Psychology from the University of Utah, ran the nonprofit Consumer Awareness Institute from Bountiful, Utah, and wrote The Case (for and) against Multi-level Marketing. He died on August 2, 2018.
What did Jon Taylor say about MLM?
His main claim was that in MLMs with what he called the "5 Red Flags" in their pay plans, about 99.6% of all participants lost money once required purchases and basic costs were subtracted. He called those companies product-based pyramid schemes.
Is the 99% figure an FTC report?
No. Jon Taylor filed his book with the FTC as a public comment, and ftc.gov still hosts it as one. It is his own analysis, not an FTC study. Direct Selling News pointed this out in 2019 after the Washington Post corrected an article that had called it an FTC report.
Where can I read The Case (for and) against Multi-level Marketing?
He gave the book away free. Several chapters are still on ftc.gov as the public comments he filed in January 2011. His own website, mlm-thetruth.com, did not load when I checked on November 22, 2026.
Is Jon Taylor still alive?
No. Jon Taylor died on August 2, 2018, at 81, according to his obituary and a memorial post by Tracy Coenen on Pink Truth.
More leaders and trainers
- Art Williams and Primerica: The Coach Who Built A.L. Williams (2026 Profile)
- Bill Britt Review (2026): Amway Crown Ambassador and the Britt Organization
- Bob Burg Review (2026): The Go-Giver and Endless Referrals for Networkers
- Bob Heilig Review (2026): Your Virtual Upline, Love-Led Growth and What His Training Costs
- Brian Carruthers Review (2026): Building an Empire, His Books and Training
- D. Gary Young: The Young Living Founder, His Story and His Record (2026)
- Dale Calvert Review (2026): No Fluff Network Marketing, His Free Podcast Course and Where He Is Now
- Dani Johnson Review (2026): First Steps To Success and Where She Is Now
Not sure network marketing is worth your time?
I put together the training I wish I had when I started. No pitch, and no pressure to join anything. Just the fundamentals that decide whether this actually works for you.
Get the free training